Business Media Blog: Smack the Dead Donkey

Tuesday, December 16, 2008

Smack the Dead Donkey

What a year it has been. We began with Emap being sold in what turned out to be the last major business media deal before the crunch. Reed announced in February the sale of RBI and then spent all year not getting it done. All the public business media companies saw their share prices collapse. No business media enterprise was exempt from redundancies. Magazine titles closed or merged. The tech sector led the way with Computing merging with IT Week. In the US PC Magazine and Techworld switched off their print editions all together to concentrate on online only.

Senior managers were ousted from Centaur, United Business Media, Wilmington and EMAP to name but a few.

What are we to expect in 2009. Is this the beginning of the end, or just the end of the beginning of the end? Can we expect a renaissance in the business media zeitgeist? It was just five years ago that city analysts were spouting the mantra that the future of media WAS business media. It was on the back of this optimism that Centaur floated at a valuation of £140m. Today the same analysts and city brokers value the same business at less than £50m.

This industry demise was not a bubble that burst, rather one that deflated rather quickly making farting and popping noises as it chaotically whizzed around the room look for somewhere to land in a flacid heap.

The tragedy is that although the crisis has been made worse by the credit crunch, so much of what has happened was avoidable. The impending crisis has been visible for a long time. I started this blog back in 2006, way before the credit crunch, and it was clear then that our model was doing its dying.

But we are where we are and it is time to turn our attention first, to what we think might happen in 2009 and then to consider what we must all do to rebuild our industry.

There will be some who say that this is all an exaggeration, that the fundamentals are good. Experienced management teams are in place, the business media has led the way in developing events and data business and looking at work flow solutions and migrating to the web. Let me remind you of the view of the CEO at Hanley Wood when he accused us back in February of "underperformance, cowardice, technophobia, inferiority, complacency, coziness, stinginess, cluelessness, disorganization and dullness."

The management teams have too often been in the same place for too long. They are mostly magazine publishers trying to adapt to the new world. Their staff are frustrated and frightened. Lemmings led by donkeys as one rather harsh observer of our industry put it to me the other day. Yet we have some hugely able leaders at the top of b2b, Jones at RBI, Heseltine at Haymarket, Gilbertson at EMAP, Levin at UBM, Weller at Incisive, Brady at Wilmington to name but a few. There is hope. There really is.

It is too easy to blame all this on the crunch or on a change in City sentiment but its more fundamental than that. Reed Elsevier worked out there was no future in the old business publishing model and tried to ditch it. EMAP lost its way and broke itself up into bits, UBM effectively fired all its global CEOs (except in Asia I think), Stirling Media Group got saved by Progressive Media unable to sustain an independent existence any longer, Centaur got rid of some its longest serving and most loyal senior executives. Haymarket said goodbye to Nick Stimpson and others. Incisive Media, perhaps the success story of the last five years, announced layoffs and ousted Rory Brown amongst others.

The tales of reflex culling are too numerous to list. But what next? When the culling is over, when the redundancies are done, when the budgets have been slashed, the overheads expunged, what if the revenue keeps falling?

A parenting guru of my acquaintance told me that it was always wrong to smack an errant child. His reason? If it doesn't work, which it often doesn't, you are left with only two choices. Smack the child harder or think of another strategy. He argued, why not deploy the other strategy, the one you will have to get to when you realise that beating your child senseless will not change his behaviour (unless you want him cowered and snivelling), before starting on the smacking.

We have been smacking the arse of business media and our businesses all year. Many of us haven't finished yet. There will be more pain to come in 2009. But let us take the advice of my parenting guru and start to deploy the strategy that will save us from nurturing a cowering, frightened and clueless industry.

As you can probably tell - I am not having a good day.

Merry Christmas.